Skip to main content

Lease or Buy a Car: Compare Total Cost

Compares the total cost of leasing a car with buying it on a loan. Adds payments, ownership costs and resale value over the same term.

Over a 48-month term, the two options are compared by their total cost, not by the monthly payment. Consider a purchase with a 20% down payment, a 7% annual interest rate on the remaining 80% of the price, and a resale value of 40% of the price at month 48. The buying total is the down payment, plus every loan payment, plus the yearly ownership costs, minus that resale value. The leasing total is every lease payment added together over the same 48 months.

A car lease covers the use of the vehicle for a fixed term, and the monthly payment may bundle depreciation, insurance, scheduled maintenance and registration into one figure. The lessee never owns the car and returns it at the end of the contract, so there is no resale value to manage. Lease contracts also set an annual mileage allowance, and the charges for exceeding it can be significant, so the terms must be read before any comparison.

Buying with an auto loan works differently. The monthly loan payment covers only principal and interest, calculated with a level-payment amortization schedule. Insurance, registration fees and maintenance are paid separately each year, and the car keeps some value that reduces the net cost. Those yearly costs are easy to overlook when the monthly payments are the only figures on the table, and they can change the result considerably over four years.

The term must be the same in both scenarios. A three-year lease compared with a five-year loan is not a like-for-like comparison, because the payments, the yearly costs and the resale value all depend on how long the car is kept. The calculator works in months internally, so the term is entered in years and converted automatically, and the rate is entered as an annual percentage. Once both totals are calculated, the monthly cost of buying shows what the ownership costs look like on a per-month basis.

The explanation below uses US units; the calculator works in either system.

The result updates automatically.

Rental

Fixed monthly contract amount, including insurance, maintenance, registration, and roadside assistance

Length of the contract in years; use the same term for an equivalent comparison

Purchase

Purchase price of the vehicle

Amount paid without financing; zero if buying entirely on credit

Annual interest rate for the auto loan; zero if paying in cash

Estimated annual auto insurance + registration + maintenance; do not include fuel

Expected sale value at the end of the term; zero if not applicable

Total difference between options

$2,471

Buying is the more affordable option overall

Total rental cost
$23,400
Total purchase cost (net of resale)
$20,929
Monthly payment (financing)
$625.81
Effective monthly cost (purchase)
$581.36
Resale value deducted
$12,000

Total purchase cost = down payment + payments + annual costs − resale value

Share

How it works

1

Enter the monthly lease payment and the lease term in years.

2

In the purchase section, enter the vehicle price and the down payment.

3

Enter the loan's annual interest rate before fees, which is the note rate in the loan agreement, or zero if the purchase is made in cash.

Formula

TCO_R = R × n | TCO_C = E + PMT × n + C_a × p − V_r | PMT = C × r × (1+r)^n / ((1+r)^n − 1) | C = Price − E | r = APR / 1200 | n = p × 12
TCO_R — Total cost of leasing: sum of all lease payments over the term
TCO_C — Net total cost of buying: down payment, all loan payments and annual ownership costs, minus resale value
R — Monthly lease payment (all-in lease contract)
n — Total number of monthly periods (term in years × 12)
E — Down payment (own capital applied to the purchase)
PMT — Monthly loan payment on the auto loan, a level payment that amortizes principal and interest
C — Financed amount (vehicle price minus down payment)
C_a — Annual ownership costs per year: insurance, registration fees and maintenance
p — Term in years
V_r — Estimated resale value at the end of the term
r — Monthly interest rate: APR divided by 1200, that is, the annual rate in percent converted to a monthly decimal
APR — Annual interest rate of the auto loan, in percent, before fees (the note rate, not the disclosed APR, which can be higher when fees apply)

How the calculation works

Lease vs Buy a Car: How to Compare Total Cost

In the United States, leasing a car is a common alternative to buying one, especially for drivers who want a predictable monthly payment and a newer vehicle every few years. The main attraction is predictability: a fixed payment that, depending on the contract, can cover depreciation, insurance, scheduled maintenance and registration. The alternative, buying with a loan or paying cash, gives ownership of the vehicle but leaves the buyer responsible for insurance, registration, repairs and the loss of value over time. A fair comparison requires the total cost of each option over the same period, which is exactly what this calculator produces.

The formula works in dollars, months and a percentage rate: the term is entered in years and converted to months, and the annual rate is entered in percent.

What is included in a lease payment?

A lease payment is an all-in monthly figure. The lessee pays for the use of the vehicle, while the leasing company keeps ownership, so the payment reflects the expected depreciation over the lease term, a finance charge and whatever services the contract bundles. Contracts vary widely. Before comparing a lease payment with the cost of buying, check whether insurance, scheduled maintenance, tire replacement, roadside assistance and registration fees are included or billed separately.

This calculator assumes a closed-end lease, in which the vehicle is returned at the end of the term with no purchase option. The lessee pays nothing further for the vehicle's value, apart from any charges for excess mileage or excess wear. The lessee never becomes the owner, which is the main drawback for people who value building an asset or who want the freedom to sell whenever they choose.

The total cost of buying: what the monthly payment does not show

When a car is bought with an auto loan, the monthly payment covers only repayment of the financed amount and the interest. The formula uses the standard level-payment amortization schedule, in which the payment is constant over the term and each payment contains a growing share of principal as the balance falls. The total cost of ownership includes several items that do not appear in that payment:

  • Auto insurance: premiums depend on the policy, the driver and the vehicle, and the loan or lease contract sets its own coverage conditions.
  • Registration fees: charges paid to register and renew the vehicle with the state, which depend on the vehicle and where it is registered.
  • Maintenance: scheduled service, tires, brakes and other wear items over the years.
  • Depreciation and resale value: a new car typically loses a significant share of its value in the first years. In the total-cost-of-ownership view, the estimated resale value at the end of the term is a partial recovery of the initial investment.

The total cost of buying is therefore: down payment + (monthly payment × number of months) + (annual ownership costs × term in years) − resale value. The down payment is a real cost because it is capital that is no longer available for other uses, which is its opportunity cost. The resale value is a benefit because it returns part of the money to the buyer and reduces the net total. The formula adds these amounts at face value over time and does not discount them. The comparison therefore ignores what the down payment could earn if it were invested elsewhere, a limitation to keep in mind when the down payment is large.

Why the formula works

The lease total is the monthly lease payment multiplied by the number of months. The purchase total uses the standard level-payment formula for a fixed-rate installment loan. The financed amount is multiplied by the monthly rate and by a growth factor for the number of months, then divided by that same growth factor minus one. The monthly rate is the annual interest rate divided by 12, and the number of months is the term in years multiplied by 12. In the formula, the symbol APR stands for the note rate entered here, which is the interest rate before fees.

The APR that lenders disclose is a different measure. It is the total cost-of-credit rate, and it includes compulsory finance charges such as lender fees, so it can be higher than the note rate when fees apply. The formula does not model those fees, and the purchase total in this calculator excludes loan fees. A loan with fees therefore costs more than the result shown here. Because both totals cover the same number of months, the comparison is like for like. The resale value enters as a subtraction because it represents money returned to the buyer at the end of the term.

When is leasing the more economical option?

Leasing tends to be comparatively favorable when the monthly payment is low relative to the monthly cost of owning the same car, when the term is short and the vehicle loses value steeply in its first years, when the down payment available is small, and when the buyer values one all-in monthly figure over ownership flexibility. Lease contracts also suit people who drive a predictable number of miles, since the mileage allowance is set in advance.

For business use, tax treatment adds a further dimension. Federal tax rules, administered by the IRS, govern how the costs of a business vehicle are deducted, and the deductible part generally follows the share of business use. This calculator does not model the tax effect, so a certified public accountant should quantify the difference before a business decides.

When is buying the more economical option?

Buying tends to be more favorable when the interest rate is low and the down payment is large, which reduces the financed amount and the total interest; when the term is long and the vehicle keeps reasonable value; and when yearly ownership costs are modest relative to the difference in monthly payments. Buyers who plan to keep the car well beyond the loan term also benefit. Once the loan is repaid, the monthly cost falls to insurance, registration and maintenance, while a lessee must sign a new lease to keep driving a newer vehicle. The advantage of ownership grows the longer the car is kept.

Edge cases

With a zero rate, the payment equals the financed amount divided by the number of months, which is the limit of the formula as the rate approaches zero. A term of one month gives a single payment equal to the financed amount plus one month of interest, while a zero-month term has no defined payment because the number of months appears in the denominator, so the term must be at least one month. A zero or negative amount has no economic meaning for a price, down payment, payment or resale value, so inputs should be zero or positive, and a zero financed amount produces a zero loan payment.

Common mistakes

The most frequent mistake is comparing only the lease payment with the loan payment and ignoring the yearly ownership costs. A lower monthly figure can produce a higher total once insurance, registration and maintenance are added over the term.

The second mistake is leaving out the resale value. A vehicle that holds its value well reduces the net cost of buying more than the monthly figures suggest, and an optimistic or pessimistic estimate can change the result.

The third mistake is comparing different terms, such as a three-year lease with a five-year loan. The term must be identical in both simulations for the comparison to be valid.

Finally, checking whether the lease payment includes everything is essential. Some offers exclude items such as tires or roadside assistance, or set mileage limits with significant charges for excess miles. Those costs must be added before the totals are compared.

When to consult a professional

This calculator compares the two scenarios using the parameters entered. For an analysis that includes tax effects, particularly for business use, a comparison of actual offers from several leasing companies and lenders, and the effect of the decision on a household or business budget over the medium term, a licensed financial professional or a certified public accountant is recommended. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau publishes consumer guidance on auto leases and auto loans, which is a useful reference when reading a contract. Federal rules such as Regulation M require lessors to disclose key lease terms, including the total of payments, so the figures in a written lease disclosure can be checked directly against this calculator's inputs.

Frequently asked questions

What is included in a car lease payment, and what is not?

Most car lease payments cover the use of the vehicle, depreciation over the term and a finance charge. Depending on the contract, they may also include insurance, scheduled maintenance, tire replacement and roadside assistance. Fuel is never included. Registration fees and sales taxes are often billed separately or added at signing, and the terms differ by lessor and state. Read the lease disclosure before comparing the payment with the monthly cost of buying, because a payment that looks lower can exclude items that the purchase total does include.

How is the total cost of buying a car calculated?

The total cost of buying is the down payment, plus all loan payments over the term, plus the annual ownership costs for each year, minus the estimated resale value at the end. Loan payments follow a level-payment amortization schedule, which keeps the payment constant over the term. Annual costs usually include auto insurance, registration fees and maintenance. The result is the net cost of buying and owning the vehicle over the chosen period, so it can be compared directly with the total of lease payments.

Can I compare a three-year lease with a five-year loan?

Not directly. For a valid comparison, both options should cover the same number of months. Different terms change the monthly payment, the yearly ownership costs added over time and the resale value, so the totals would not reflect the same period. If the only lease on offer runs three years and the loan runs five, compare both over the three-year period, using an estimated resale value at month 36 for the loan, or model both at five years with explicit assumptions for the second lease term.

Does resale value change the comparison a lot?

Yes, often significantly. A vehicle that holds its value well, such as a model in high demand on the used market, lowers the net total cost of buying. A vehicle that loses value quickly in its first years makes buying more costly by comparison. Estimate resale value realistically by checking recent sale prices of similar vehicles with similar mileage and condition, using published used-vehicle valuation guides or listings from local dealers. The resale value is an estimate, and actual values depend on condition and mileage at the end of the term.

Is leasing better for tax purposes for a business?

It depends on the situation, and this calculator does not model the tax effect. Business vehicle costs are treated under federal tax rules administered by the IRS, and the deductible part generally follows the share of business use, whether the car is leased or bought. The rules depend on the vehicle, the type of business and how the car is used. A certified public accountant can quantify the difference for a specific situation.

When should I talk to a professional before deciding?

A professional review is especially useful when the vehicle is used for business and tax treatment could change the decision, when you want to compare actual offers from several leasing companies and lenders on equal terms, or when the decision affects a household or business budget over several years and many variables are uncertain, such as a long term, an expensive vehicle or uncertain annual costs. A certified public accountant can answer tax questions, and a licensed financial professional can review loan and budget questions. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau publishes guidance on auto leases and loans that can help you read the contract.

Related calculators

By RivoCalc · Reviewed under our editorial methodology · Updated August 14, 2026

This calculator provides an estimate for informational purposes only and is not financial advice. Actual results depend on the terms of each lease or loan contract, the lessor's and lender's fees, your state's registration and tax rules, and your personal tax situation. For financial decisions, consult a qualified professional or your financial institution.